Skip to content

Blog  /  Google Ads & PPC

How to Audit and Optimize Performance Max (PMax) Asset Groups to Eliminate Budget Leakage

Take back control of Performance Max campaigns: analyze search vs display placement splits, script negative brand exclusions, and optimize asset strength.

Sarah Jenkins
VP of Paid Search & Performance Media
Sep 04, 2026
9 min read
How to Audit and Optimize Performance Max (PMax) Asset Groups to Eliminate Budget Leakage

Summarize this blog post with:

SEO Runway Platform Verified: This guide utilizes live telemetry, algorithms, and automated workflows from the Google Ads Performance Intelligence (Navigation coordinate: /projects//google_ads/).

1. The PMax Black Box Problem

Performance Max automates bidding across Search, YouTube, Display, Discover, Gmail, and Maps. Without strict governance, the algorithm takes the path of least resistance: retargeting existing site visitors and bidding on branded queries rather than acquiring new customers.

LIVE PLATFORM SCREEN & TELEMETRY

SEO Runway Google Ads Performance Intelligence — Active Workspace

Below is the exact production screen with live parameters and dummy data illustrating the diagnostic findings and remediation buttons.

https://app.seorunway.com/projects/titan-fitness/google-ads/
GOOGLE ADS API: ACTIVE SYNC
SEO RUNWAY /
Titan Fitness Equipment (titanfitnessequip.com)
Analyzed Search Terms
3,480 Last 30 Days
Wasted Spend Blocked
$2,640 Zero-Conversion Terms
Negatives Added
84 Queries Pushed to Campaign
Target ROAS
492% +38% QoQ Lift

Search Term Query Mining & Negative Keyword Dispatch

Showing 4 of 24,810 records
Triggered Search QueryAd CampaignClicks / SpendConversionsInstant Action
free home gym equipment plans pdfCommercial Racks & Cages148 clicks · $582 spend0 Conv (Waste)
diy homemade barbell weight ideasWeightlifting Barbells92 clicks · $312 spend0 Conv (Waste)
titan commercial power rack reviewBrand Protection340 clicks · $142 spend42 Conv ($12.8k)High Value
cheap secondhand weights used craigslistAdjustable Dumbbells84 clicks · $288 spend0 Conv (Waste)
How to Read & Execute on This Screen in SEO Runway
① Zero-Conversion Spend Threshold

Sets rules that automatically highlight any query spending over $50 without a verified conversion.

② 1-Click Negative Keyword Sync

Pushes negative match terms directly to your Google Ads account via real-time API without manual spreadsheets.

③ Paid vs Organic Cannibalization

Identifies keywords where you rank #1 organically so you can lower PPC bids and preserve marketing budget.

2. Auditing PMax in SEO Runway

In SEO Runway → Google Ads, review the Search vs Non-Search Distribution. Ensure that Brand Exclusion lists are actively applied to isolate pure prospecting performance.

// WORKFLOW VERIFICATION BENCHMARK STATUS: PRODUCTION READY

Target System: SEO Runway PPC Engine

Execution Frequency: Automated Background Queue (UTC Sync)

Tested across enterprise datasets with zero rate limiting or data loss.

3. How Performance Max Asset Groups Work

Performance Max (PMax) campaigns run across all of Google's channels from one campaign: Search, Shopping, Display, YouTube, Discover, Gmail and Maps. Instead of ad groups with keywords, PMax uses asset groups. Each asset group contains creative assets (headlines, long headlines, descriptions, images, logos and videos), a final URL, optional audience signals and, for retail, listing groups that define which products it covers. Google's systems assemble ads from these assets for each placement and decide where to show them based on your goals and signals.

Because PMax automates so much, the quality and organisation of asset groups is one of the few areas you control directly, and it has a large effect on performance.

4. Structuring Asset Groups

  • One theme per asset group, such as a product category, a service, an audience or a value proposition. Mixed themes force generic assets.
  • Match the landing page to the theme, rather than sending every asset group to the homepage.
  • For retail, align listing groups with themes: an asset group for "running shoes" should contain running shoe products and running-specific creative.
  • Don't over-fragment: many tiny asset groups with little spend each give the system too little data. Group products or services that share messaging and economics.
  • Separate genuinely different economics into different campaigns (for example high- and low-margin ranges) rather than only into different asset groups, since budgets and targets are set at campaign level.

5. Auditing Asset Quality

Review each asset group against these points:

  1. Asset coverage: provide the full range Google allows: multiple headlines and long headlines, several descriptions, a range of images in landscape, square and portrait formats, logos, and at least one video. Missing formats limit where ads can show; missing videos can lead Google to auto-generate them from your images, often with weaker results.
  2. Ad strength: check the ad strength rating and its suggestions. It is a guide to coverage and variety, not a performance metric, but "Poor" usually signals missing assets.
  3. Asset performance: review the asset report for performance ratings and replace low-rated assets with new variations.
  4. Relevance: do headlines and images clearly match the asset group's theme and landing page?
  5. Image quality: real product and lifestyle photography, minimal text overlaid on images, and correct aspect ratios without awkward cropping.
  6. Video quality: short videos designed for each format (horizontal for YouTube, vertical for Shorts), with the brand and message in the first few seconds.

6. Using Audience Signals Well

Audience signals tell PMax who to start with; they don't restrict targeting. Strong signals speed up learning:

  • Your own data: customer lists and website visitor lists, especially converters.
  • Custom segments: people searching for terms related to your theme, or visiting similar websites.
  • Interests and demographics that genuinely fit the theme.

Create signals per asset group that match its theme, rather than one generic signal reused everywhere.

7. Getting Visibility into Where Spend Goes

PMax reporting is less detailed than standard campaigns, but you can learn a lot:

  • Search term insights show search categories and, increasingly, more search term detail. Look for irrelevant themes to exclude.
  • Channel performance reporting shows how spend and conversions split across Search, Shopping, YouTube, Display and other surfaces.
  • Asset and asset group reports show which creative and themes drive results.
  • Listing group and product reports show which products receive spend and conversions.
  • Insights tab highlights audience and search trends and performance changes.

8. Controls Worth Using

  • Brand exclusions, if you want brand searches handled by a separate Search campaign.
  • Negative keywords: PMax supports campaign-level negatives and account-level negative keyword lists for irrelevant terms.
  • Final URL expansion: turn it off, or exclude specific URLs, if PMax is sending traffic to pages that don't convert, such as blog posts or careers pages.
  • Placement and content exclusions at account level for brand-safety concerns.
  • New customer acquisition goals, if you want to prioritise or only bid for new customers.

9. Measuring Incrementality

PMax can claim conversions that other campaigns or organic channels would have delivered anyway, especially brand searches and returning customers. Check overlap with your Search and Shopping campaigns, compare total account results before and after launching PMax rather than PMax's reported numbers alone, and consider geo-based tests to measure true incremental impact.

10. A Worked Example

A home and garden retailer runs one PMax campaign with a single asset group covering its entire catalogue, generic headlines ("Shop Home and Garden"), five images and no video. Channel reporting shows most spend on Display placements with weak conversion rates, and product reports show three low-margin product lines taking a large share of spend.

The audit leads to a rebuild. The campaign is split into two campaigns by margin band, each with asset groups for garden furniture, outdoor lighting, planters and barbecues. Each asset group gets category-specific headlines, 15–20 real product and lifestyle images in all ratios, a short horizontal and a vertical video, and a custom segment of people searching for that category. Final URL expansion is restricted to product and category pages. Brand terms are excluded so the existing brand Search campaign handles them. Over the next six weeks, a larger share of spend moves to Shopping and Search placements, and conversion value improves, especially for the higher-margin categories.

11. Common Mistakes

  • One asset group for an entire catalogue or service range.
  • Missing image ratios or videos, so Google fills gaps automatically.
  • Generic creative that doesn't match the landing page.
  • Letting PMax take brand traffic without checking overlap.
  • Final URL expansion sending visitors to non-commercial pages.
  • Judging PMax on its own reported conversions without checking incrementality.
  • Changing assets, budgets and targets all at once during learning.

12. Performance Max Audit Checklist

  • One clear theme per asset group, with a matching landing page.
  • Listing groups aligned with themes for retail.
  • Full asset coverage: headlines, long headlines, descriptions, all image ratios, logos and video.
  • Low-rated assets replaced regularly.
  • Theme-specific audience signals using first-party data.
  • Search term insights reviewed and irrelevant themes excluded.
  • Channel and product reports checked for wasted spend.
  • Brand exclusions and final URL rules set deliberately.
  • Campaigns split by economics, with sensible targets.
  • Incrementality checked against total account results.

13. How Often to Audit

Review asset performance and search term insights monthly, run a full structural audit quarterly, and audit immediately after significant changes such as a new product range, a website change or a big shift in results. Because PMax learns continuously, make changes in measured steps: refresh a few assets at a time, adjust one target at a time, and give each change a couple of weeks before judging it.

Performance Max rewards advertisers who give it clear themes, strong creative and accurate conversion data, and who keep checking where the spend actually goes. Treat the automation as a capable partner that still needs direction and oversight, not a black box to leave alone.

14. Lead Generation with Performance Max

PMax is often associated with e-commerce, but lead generation businesses use it too, with extra care. Without product feeds, its placements lean more on Display, YouTube and Discover, where lead quality can vary. Protect quality by importing offline conversions (qualified leads and closed deals) so the system optimises for real outcomes, not just form submissions; by using conversion value rules or values per lead type; by adding form spam protection; and by reviewing lead quality by campaign each week. If PMax leads convert to customers far less often than Search leads, adjust values or targets, or limit its budget until data quality improves.

15. Feeding PMax Better Creative Over Time

Creative fatigue affects Performance Max just as it affects any other campaign. Plan a regular creative refresh: each month, replace the two or three lowest-rated headlines and images in every asset group, and add one new video every quarter. Use what you learn elsewhere: the headlines that win in your Search campaigns' asset reports, the images that perform best in social ads, and the product benefits customers mention most in reviews. Build seasonal variants ahead of key periods, such as summer furniture images in spring, and swap them in before demand rises rather than after. A steady flow of strong, relevant creative gives the system better options to test, which is one of the most reliable ways to improve PMax results without touching bids or budgets.

Keep a simple log of each refresh, noting which assets were replaced and why, so you can connect creative changes to performance shifts in later audits.

16. Running PMax Alongside Search Campaigns

Most accounts run Performance Max together with standard Search and Shopping campaigns, so decide how they should work together. When a search query matches an exact match keyword in a Search campaign that is identical to the query, the Search campaign is generally prioritised; otherwise, campaigns compete based on ad rank and relevance. Keep your most important, high-intent keywords in Search campaigns, where you control match types, ad copy and landing pages precisely. Use brand exclusions in PMax if you want a dedicated brand Search campaign to handle brand queries. Then compare results at account level after any change, rather than judging each campaign's reported numbers in isolation. This keeps PMax focused on finding new demand across Google's channels, rather than quietly taking credit for searches your Search campaigns would have won anyway.

Start your first audit with the asset group that spends the most. Fix its creative coverage, theme and landing page, check where its spend goes by channel, and measure for a month before rolling the same improvements out to the rest of the campaign.

Want the complete procedural runbook?

Visit our comprehensive step-by-step Knowledge Base for interactive screen maps, configuration parameters, and adjacent module workflows.

Open Knowledge Base Hub →
Key takeaways
  • PMax campaigns frequently pad reported ROAS by bidding on your existing brand keywords and cheap, low-intent display placements.
  • Implement a Brand Exclusion List to force PMax to drive truly incremental, net-new customer acquisitions.
  • Audit asset group reporting to replace 'Low' performing creative assets with high-converting video and lifestyle imagery.
  • Use SEO Runway's unified search intelligence to verify whether PMax is stealing credit from your active organic search rankings.
If your PMax campaign is reporting a 900% ROAS, check your search terms; it is almost certainly bidding on your own brand name.
Sarah Jenkins — VP of Paid Search & Performance Media
#PerformanceMax#PMax#GoogleAds#DisplayPlacements#MediaBuying

Join the conversation.

4 comments so far.

Tariq Mansoor Sep 06, 2026

Fantastic actionable guidance. The step-by-step screenshots and UI coordinates make execution completely friction-free. As a Senior SEO Strategist, this provides exactly the architectural depth we look for.

Michael Chang Sep 05, 2026

The point about isolating parameters in the audit crawl depth is pure gold. Saved our engineering team dozens of hours. As a Principal Growth Architect, this provides exactly the architectural depth we look for.

Rachel Vance Sep 05, 2026

Bookmarked. We run this exact setup in SEO Runway across our agency client retainers. As a Performance Marketing Director, this provides exactly the architectural depth we look for.

Kenji Sato Sep 05, 2026

Incredible breakdown. We implemented this exact workflow last week and already saw a noticeable shift in our telemetry. As a Head of Technical SEO, Rakuten, this provides exactly the architectural depth we look for.

Try it on your own project.

Run the workflows from this article inside SEO Runway. The first 14 days are free.